Doctor Kouda
Rising Soul
PL: 58,708; Chaos Form(x7), Muenster Form(x12) Items: One-Use SpacePod, Heavy Weights (1/4 of PL), Royal Spaceship, 2 Extra Seats, Tier 4 Gravity Chamber; Tier 1 Shop, "I Love Bao" T-shirt, Tier 3 Healing Chamber, 1 5kPL Guard, 1 10k PL Guard; Zeni: 176
|
Post by Doctor Kouda on Apr 30, 2015 22:23:56 GMT
All I knew was that Cipher wanted to fight Red Eclipse members. Not sure where that went.
I pretty much agree with what Azurai suggested however there is one problem.
You will literally be limiting/restricting threads to community members through power control.
|
|
|
Post by Hyoza on Apr 30, 2015 22:24:04 GMT
It's been agreed unofficially in the past that major plot-influencing events, especially those which result in widespread destruction, cannot and should never be allowed to occur in closed/solo threads.
Plus it's common sense. To do this in a closed, non-DE thread is essentially meta-gaming, to take a stab at Avalon with a nice cozy OOC forcefield of closed-threaded-ness around you.
|
|
Mayze
Moderator
PL: 250,469
Super Saiyan(x12) MSSJ(x15)
Zeni: 849
Shoki: 2,965
Tag: @gagelange10
OOC Name: Gage
Posts: 1,232
|
Post by Mayze on Apr 30, 2015 22:24:59 GMT
Perhaps this should be officially stated, mainly so that we don't run into this fuckup ever again.
|
|
|
Post by Cipher 24 on Apr 30, 2015 22:25:12 GMT
Komoto, while I said it was ok for the Red Eclipse to target Porsalynne to get at Cipher, how you went about and did it was all you. There were so many, more subtle ways you could have done it. Kidnap her, heck, even turn a gun on her. Instead, you went for the biggest, noisiest method possible, all the while proclaiming who's behind it all.
As for Hitora, while Reikiko explained herself, I'm surprised the others haven't gone after him. Though I think Hitora wont be a problem much longer anyway.
|
|
|
Post by Cipher 24 on Apr 30, 2015 22:27:11 GMT
Komoto, while I did say it would be cool story wise for the Red Eclipse to target Porsalynne to get at Cipher, how you did it was all you. There were so many other, more subtle, methods to accomplish this. Instead you went for the biggest, noisiest method possible.
As for Hitora, while I am surprised Kaula and Walker aren't going after him, he may not be an issue much longer.
|
|
Doctor Kouda
Rising Soul
PL: 58,708; Chaos Form(x7), Muenster Form(x12) Items: One-Use SpacePod, Heavy Weights (1/4 of PL), Royal Spaceship, 2 Extra Seats, Tier 4 Gravity Chamber; Tier 1 Shop, "I Love Bao" T-shirt, Tier 3 Healing Chamber, 1 5kPL Guard, 1 10k PL Guard; Zeni: 176
|
Post by Doctor Kouda on Apr 30, 2015 22:27:44 GMT
What is fundamentally flawed and what is clearly and concisely written as a rule in clear for new members is different. I'm not necessarily disagreeing with you (Rei) but I don't think (as far as I'm aware) the accused were aware of the rule and how strictly it would be enforced.
And to be clear, it is not the Red Eclipse's objective to bomb the island place I've barely heard of until now. If we ever do choose to do an assault like that on anybody's "territory", I would gladly have and expect it to be something like Open DE since that would be more epic.
|
|
|
Post by President Bao on May 1, 2015 9:38:54 GMT
Howdy Folks. To clarify; (and lets not turn this into something negative, we're all here to have fun ) Whenever something of a large enough scale or importance occurs, it becomes a Saga. A Saga thread is open in nature, and involves the possibility of death (the victor of the saga essentially decides the outcome, such as for example reducing a city to rubble, stealing a dragonball, killing a participant, etc.) alongside some nicely beefed up grade bonuses. Closed non-saga threads may lead in to saga threads depending on their nature. When this happens, the original thread is closed(and it's participants graded) and the official Saga tagged thread is made directly where the last took off. For example, the Z fighters sleeping at kame house, listening for news of cell and waiting it out, might have been a closed thread. When the androids arrived however, the closed thread is ended, and a new one where piccolo challenges 17 (a saga thread) begins.You can't be 'forced' into a saga thread, you may choose not to engage/pursue your goal and instead escape(only when it starts mind you, if you stick around or enter later, it then becomes your opponents choice whether they let you escape or not - even if your opponent is far weaker), however this allows your opponent to pursue their goals in much the same way as them 'winning' would. For instance, if piccolo didn't fight the androids, they may have blown up kame house/ been allowed to find goku. Alternatively, when gero fled after his defeat(due to his android racial ability), the Z fighters were allowed to chase him and ultimately find his lab, because that was their goal.
Ideally, people act in the best interest of good story, and have a bit of give and take from *both* sides. We are after all playing a game where creating a cool story with our characters is the goal. ----- In this case for example, Komoto might escape and not engage when people step in. However, the bombings would give Avalons defenders a reason to begin searching for the perpetrators(the damage from them deemed minimal, since they are technically the 'winners' and so decide the severity of the outcome), leading to possible further plot down the road if desired. From what I read here, it almost sounds more like people are trying to force OOC punishments on Komoto, rather than align this plot in an interesting way and come to a fun solution. It's also clear for example that the Z Fighters support the tyrannical, mass-murdering president-kidnapping regime of the Blue Banner Army, since they very happily work alongside them without conflict. ------ One thing however which has caught my eye:This pertains to Reikiko, but is important for everyone to be aware of so I am mentioning it here: You are not allowed to use alternate accounts in a manner which directly benefits your alt. That would include for example evil reikiko coming to help tea-party reikiko defend avalon. Avalon is not associated with evil-rei as far as I am aware, therefore evil reikiko's presence and benefactory nature is questionable at best. Minions and guards are characters you can buy to help your 'main', alternate accounts are meant to maintain separation, (especially in saga matters, and when it comes to master/monarch benefits).
|
|
|
Post by Toma on May 1, 2015 10:18:27 GMT
It's also clear for example that the Z Fighters support the tyrannical, mass-murdering president-kidnapping regime of the Blue Banner Army, since they very happily work alongside them without conflict. Yeaaaa no. It's more of a "Hey, these are our common enemies right now" situation. Toma (And the Z-Fighters) do NOT approve of the BBA's methods, but they're aware they can't do shit to the BBA right now. So they're tolerating them more than anything. Read a few of my recent posts, and you'll see. :3
|
|
|
Post by President Bao on May 1, 2015 10:37:49 GMT
Very true, just teasing (though you can do more than you think, raw power alone doesn't dictate saga development and a victory doesn't always mean defeating your opponent in combat - sometimes it's about getting a friend to safety, or laying down your underground resistance, or even just making a cool story in some way - gambits are always fun)
|
|
|
Post by Reikiko on May 1, 2015 12:48:12 GMT
------ One thing however which has caught my eye:This pertains to Reikiko, but is important for everyone to be aware of so I am mentioning it here: You are not allowed to use alternate accounts in a manner which directly benefits your alt. That would include for example evil reikiko coming to help tea-party reikiko defend avalon. Avalon is not associated with evil-rei as far as I am aware, therefore evil reikiko's presence and benefactory nature is questionable at best. Umm questionable at best? She just discovered that they are bombing Good Rei's home, keeping in mind that those two are a Namekian-style splitting (and that Evil Rei is aware of the consequences this holds) she isn't going to sit idle while people are endangering the island, and possibly her helpless other self. Yami Rei, as shown so far pretty much used the splitting as a means to make Good Rei become more or less a social character. She's supposed to be able to experience the light-hearted/happy moments while Yami Rei is the one doing all the dirty deeds/evil business to ensure they can complete the purpose behind their creation. Sure, Avalon isn't directly associated with evil-rei, but some of its inhabitants are.
|
|
|
Post by Deleted on May 1, 2015 12:57:08 GMT
I think we need something more clear than just having something turned into a Saga and then everything else being rather basic. Shouldn't we have some sort of prerequisite or clearer definition in place to automatically set topics as Faction DE, Saga(essentially Open DE) and then a normal, closed thread? This subject seems to be making a lot of people angry.
|
|
Doctor Kouda
Rising Soul
PL: 58,708; Chaos Form(x7), Muenster Form(x12) Items: One-Use SpacePod, Heavy Weights (1/4 of PL), Royal Spaceship, 2 Extra Seats, Tier 4 Gravity Chamber; Tier 1 Shop, "I Love Bao" T-shirt, Tier 3 Healing Chamber, 1 5kPL Guard, 1 10k PL Guard; Zeni: 176
|
Post by Doctor Kouda on May 1, 2015 14:46:58 GMT
The fact of the matter is that Cipher innocently messaged us because he wanted villains to oppose his heroic character. That's what the Red Eclipse is here on the forums for so we happily obliged. We've been talking about going after his loved one as a weakness to put more on the line for Cipher's character. We agreed that would be cool so Komoto went to attack an npc. Komoto had no intent in doing harm to the island place or whoever lives there. The explosion was clearly just roleplay flavor, that's not hard to see. The target was literally just one npc that the thread party agreed to. Clearly, moderators got personally offended and punished Komoto for simply RPing a thread with Cipher. I'm really disappointed with how this situation was handled. We wanted a thread with Cipher and Cipher only, that's it. We attacked a single NPC who happened to be situated on the island because we agreed that we wanted that to happen, that's it.
|
|
|
Post by Kaula on May 1, 2015 17:53:45 GMT
The fact of the matter is that Cipher innocently messaged us because he wanted villains to oppose his heroic character. That's what the Red Eclipse is here on the forums for so we happily obliged. We've been talking about going after his loved one as a weakness to put more on the line for Cipher's character. We agreed that would be cool so Komoto went to attack an npc. Komoto had no intent in doing harm to the island place or whoever lives there. The explosion was clearly just roleplay flavor, that's not hard to see. The target was literally just one npc that the thread party agreed to. Clearly, moderators got personally offended and punished Komoto for simply RPing a thread with Cipher. I'm really disappointed with how this situation was handled. We wanted a thread with Cipher and Cipher only, that's it. We attacked a single NPC who happened to be situated on the island because we agreed that we wanted that to happen, that's it. We literally have no problems with you guys being villains, even though Komoto swears left right up and down in OOC that you all are NOT villains in the Cbox all the time, the problem simply was a lack of communication, a lack of understanding a few things, and some of us being pissed that our faction home was being attacked. That's simply it. There's no if/ands/or/buts about it, you know? But next time, understand maybe you shouldn't use West Capitol as the city? Maybe use an unnamed smaller one..? But then again, you know, trial and error. Learn from mistakes. That kind of thing. I'm still looking forward to RPing with you all in the future, especially your character, Kouda.
|
|
|
Post by Pieter Wolfbane on May 1, 2015 20:40:43 GMT
Okay... I'm very confused by what's happened.
Non-DE thread attacking loved one. Processed as a means of character development. However, attacking inside enemy base...? If someone could give me a small, concise explanation in this thread or pm, that'd be appreciated.
|
|
|
Post by Kaula on May 1, 2015 20:46:21 GMT
Pretty much, Pieter, this started as character development, but because Komoto took this as a chance to send suicide bombers to attack Avalon, a faction base, where the character's loved one was, we got up in arms about it.
We do not mind character development. What we do mind is the attack on a faction base, which we were being told we couldn't respond to. At all.
|
|